Automated decisions under Law 25: what to tell candidates and how they can respond
When software alone turns a candidate down, Quebec’s privacy act requires a notice, an explanation on request and a chance to be heard by a person. What each duty means in hiring.
6 minute readQuebec: Law 25 and French
If a hiring decision about a candidate is based exclusively on automated processing of their personal information, section 12.1 of Quebec’s private-sector privacy act sets three duties. You must tell the candidate that the decision was automated, at the latest when you tell them the decision. On request, you must tell them what personal information was used, the reasons and the principal factors and parameters behind the decision, and that they have the right to have the information corrected. And you must give them the opportunity to submit observations to a member of your staff who is in a position to review the decision.
What counts as a decision made by software alone
The section applies only when the decision rests exclusively on automated processing. The Commission d’accès à l’information gives a hiring example in its recruitment guidance: sorting software that automatically rejects some applications, with no person involved.
Patterns that can fall inside the rule:
- A knock-out question that closes every application answering “no”.
- A score threshold below which applications are rejected without anyone reading them.
- A chat or assessment that ends a candidate’s process when an answer falls outside a set range.
A tool that ranks or suggests while a person reads the application and makes the call is a different situation. The Act does not say how much a person has to do. A useful test: for each candidate you turned down, can you name the person who looked at the application and point to the reason they recorded? Where the answer is no, treat the decision as automated.
That test catches the quiet cases. If a recruiter reads the top 50 of 900 ranked applications and the other 850 receive a rejection that no one looked at, the Act gives no clear answer. In our view, it is hard to say a person decided those 850, and the cautious course is to treat those rejections as automated.
What to tell the candidate, and when
The notice is due no later than the moment you inform the candidate of the decision, so the natural place for it is the rejection message itself. Keep it short and specific, for example:
“This decision was made automatically, based on your answer to the question about night shifts. You can ask us what information we used and the main reasons for the decision, ask us to correct your information, and send your comments to a member of our team who can review the decision. Reply to this email to do any of these.”
The Commission also says the use of artificial intelligence in hiring should be communicated to candidates from the start of the process. If your application page says nothing about automated screening, the rejection notice should not be the first the candidate hears of it.
What to explain on request
When a candidate asks, you owe them three things:
- The personal information used to render the decision.
- The reasons, and the principal factors and parameters, that led to it.
- Their right to have the personal information used corrected.
Explain at the level of the decision, in plain words. “The position requires a valid forklift operator certificate. Your application said you do not hold one, and our system closes applications that answer no to that question.” For a score, name the criteria and the threshold that applied: “Your answers scored 58 out of 100, and applications below 65 were closed.” A general description of how the vendor’s model works does not tell a candidate why they were turned down.
The Act sets no separate deadline for these explanations. A request for a copy of the information itself can also be an access request, which the person in charge of the protection of personal information must answer in writing within 30 days of receiving it. Answering every request within that time keeps you on the safe side of both rules.
Keep what you need to answer. Information used to make a decision about a person must be kept for at least one year after the decision.
How candidates can respond
The candidate must be able to submit observations to a member of your staff who is in a position to review the decision. A no-reply address does not meet that. In our reading, a chatbot does not either: the Act speaks of a member of the personnel who is in a position to review the decision, which points to a person. The person who reads the reply should have the authority to reopen the application.
If the candidate says the information was wrong, correct it and look at the decision again with the corrected information. Record who reviewed the decision and why it stood or changed.
A worked example
Take a hypothetical distribution centre on Montreal’s South Shore hiring 60 order pickers for night shifts. It receives 900 applications. The form asks “Can you work from 11 p.m. to 7 a.m.?” and the system rejects the 210 applicants who answer no, within the hour, without anyone reading their applications.
Those 210 decisions are based exclusively on automated processing, so each rejection email carries the notice above. Suppose nine candidates reply. Six say they misread the question and can work nights: a recruiter corrects their answers, reopens the applications and records the reason. Three ask why they were turned down: the recruiter explains the night-shift requirement, the answer each gave and the rule that applied.
The employer could avoid section 12.1 altogether by sending “no” answers to a queue where a recruiter reads each application and records a reason before anyone is turned down. That takes more time per application. It also catches the applicant who answered no but explained in a cover letter that they can move to nights in two weeks.
Related duties around automated tools
- Technology with functions that can identify, locate or profile a candidate requires telling the candidate first, and explaining how to turn those functions on. The Act defines profiling as assessing characteristics such as work performance, interests or behaviour, so matching a candidate against other openings can qualify.
- Acquiring or developing an information system that handles personal information requires a privacy impact assessment, and the Commission says an employer must carry one out before using an AI system in hiring.
- Failing to inform a person of an automated decision, or to give them the opportunity to submit observations, can lead to a monetary administrative penalty. The maximum is $50,000 for a natural person and, in all other cases, $10,000,000 or 2% of worldwide turnover for the preceding fiscal year, whichever is greater.
In TalentInitiator, advancing, holding or rejecting a candidate takes a person and a written reason, so no decision rests only on automated processing; every candidate can still open a “Why this decision” page and ask for a review by a person. Our Law 25 explainer has the details.
How to read this post
This post explains the rules in general terms, as they stood on the date above. It is not legal advice for your organization.
Sources
- Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector, s. 12.1 (decisions based exclusively on automated processing) In force since September 22, 2023Pending legal review
- CAI guidance on recruitment and hiring
- Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector, s. 8.1 (identification, location and profiling functions) In force since September 22, 2023Pending legal review
- Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector, s. 3.3 (privacy impact assessment) In force since September 22, 2023Pending legal review
- Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector, s. 11 (keeping information used to make a decision) In force since September 22, 2023
- Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector, ss. 27 to 34 (access requests and the 30-day reply)
- Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector, ss. 90.1 and 90.12 (monetary administrative penalties) In force since September 22, 2023