Skip to main content

Which privacy law applies to your hiring in Canada?

Two facts decide it: where you operate and whether you are federally regulated. How PIPEDA and the Quebec, Alberta and BC laws divide up candidate information.

6 minute readPrivacy and records

Two facts decide it: where your organization operates, and whether it is federally regulated. When an employer hires for itself, PIPEDA, the federal law, covers its applicants and employees only if it is a federally regulated business such as a bank, an airline or a telecommunications company. Quebec, Alberta and British Columbia have their own private-sector laws, and those do cover hiring by provincially regulated employers in their province. In Ontario and the other provinces without such a law, a provincially regulated employer hiring for itself may find that no general privacy statute covers its candidate files. Staffing agencies sit apart, because recruiting for clients is their business.

What PIPEDA covers

PIPEDA applies to an organization in two situations. The first is personal information it collects, uses or discloses in the course of commercial activities. The second is information about an employee of, or an applicant for employment with, the organization, that it collects, uses or discloses in connection with the operation of a federal work, undertaking or business.

The second clause is the one that matters for an employer’s own hiring, and it treats applicants exactly like employees. The Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada (OPC) gives examples of federally regulated businesses: banks, airlines and airports, telecommunications companies, radio and television broadcasters, and interprovincial or international transportation companies. The OPC also treats organizations in Yukon, the Northwest Territories and Nunavut as federally regulated, so on its reading PIPEDA covers their employee information too.

For everyone else, the OPC’s position is plain: PIPEDA does not apply to employee information in provincially regulated organizations. That statement is about employees. Applying it to applicants is our inference, but the Act points the same way: its only clause on applicants is the one tied to federal works.

Quebec, Alberta and British Columbia

These three provinces have private-sector privacy laws that have been declared substantially similar to PIPEDA. A provincially regulated organization subject to one of them is generally exempt from PIPEDA for what it collects, uses and discloses within that province. Unlike PIPEDA, each of these laws reaches candidate and employee information held by provincially regulated employers. A federally regulated employer stays under PIPEDA for its employees and applicants wherever it operates.

  • Quebec. The Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector, as amended by Law 25, applies to recruitment. The Commission d’accès à l’information (CAI) has published guidance on what an employer may collect at each stage of hiring, and it says the employer stays legally responsible when it works through a third party such as a staffing agency. Acquiring recruitment software is also a project that requires a privacy impact assessment.
  • Alberta. The Personal Information Protection Act covers “personal employee information”, which it defines to include information about a potential employee that the organization reasonably requires to establish the relationship.
  • British Columbia. The province’s Personal Information Protection Act covers “employee personal information”: information collected, used or disclosed solely for the purposes reasonably required to establish, manage or end an employment relationship.

Ontario and the other provinces

In Ontario, Manitoba, Saskatchewan and the four Atlantic provinces, PIPEDA is the general private-sector privacy law. But it reaches commercial activity, and the OPC does not treat an employer’s handling of its own employee information as covered unless the employer is federally regulated.

So an Ontario retailer that is not federally regulated, hiring cashiers for its own stores, may have no general privacy statute governing its candidates’ résumés. That reading follows from the wording of PIPEDA and from the OPC’s position, but it turns on the facts, and it is worth confirming with counsel before you rely on it. It does not leave the employer without rules either: if it has 25 or more employees on the day it posts, Ontario’s Employment Standards Act requires it to keep each public job posting and its application form for three years after the posting comes down.

Staffing agencies

An agency that finds and places candidates for clients is doing something different from an employer filling its own roles. PIPEDA defines a commercial activity as any transaction, act or conduct, or any regular course of conduct, that is of a commercial character. The Act does not name recruiting, but placing candidates for a fee would, on a plain reading of that definition, have that character. A provincially regulated agency should therefore expect PIPEDA to govern its candidate files in Ontario and the other PIPEDA provinces, and the provincial act to govern them in Quebec, Alberta or British Columbia.

Two details are easy to miss.

  • Information that crosses a border. The OPC’s position is that PIPEDA applies to personal information that crosses provincial or national borders in the course of commercial activities, even in the three provinces with their own law, and that an Alberta organization subject to Alberta’s act must follow PIPEDA for those transactions. On that view, an Alberta agency that sends a candidate’s profile to a client in Vancouver must follow PIPEDA for that transfer.
  • The agency as employer. An agency also employs its own staff and, often, its assignment employees. That information follows the employer rules above, which may differ from the rules for the candidates in its database.

Six quick cases

  • A bank hiring tellers in Ontario: PIPEDA covers the applicants.
  • An interprovincial trucking company hiring drivers in Manitoba: PIPEDA, because the business is federally regulated.
  • A manufacturer in Calgary hiring for its own plant: Alberta’s act.
  • A restaurant group in Vancouver hiring servers: British Columbia’s act.
  • A distribution centre in Laval hiring 40 warehouse workers: Quebec’s act, including Law 25’s impact-assessment duty and, if a decision is made by automated processing alone, its notice duty.
  • A retail chain in Ontario hiring for its own stores: probably no general privacy statute for the candidate files, while the posting rules still apply.

An organization that operates in several provinces may have to comply with more than one law, sometimes for the same file. The OPC suggests working through it in order: the province where you operate, then the definition of “organization” in each law that might apply, then each law’s application section.

A practical default

Whichever law applies, the same habits keep you on safe ground. Collect only what the job requires and say why you collect it. Keep candidate information for a set period, then delete it. Let candidates see what you hold about them and correct it. These are the core of PIPEDA’s principles, and the OPC notes that the Alberta and British Columbia acts share them.

Name one person who answers for candidate information, and tell candidates how to reach them. If your hiring later turns out to fall under one of these laws, you will not have to rebuild your process.

How we handle it

TalentInitiator’s compliance centre lists the obligations that apply in each jurisdiction where an organization hires, and Quebec mode turns on the Law 25 defaults. Our Law 25 explainer and security page describe what the product does with candidate information.

How to read this post

This post explains the rules in general terms, as they stood on the date above. It is not legal advice for your organization.

Sources

All posts