Skip to main content

CASL for recruiters: when a message to a candidate needs consent

Canada’s anti-spam law requires consent for commercial electronic messages. How to tell whether a recruiting email or text is one, which messages fall outside the rule, and what consent must look like.

7 minute readSourcing and outreach

Canada’s Anti-Spam Legislation  (another site) (CASL) prohibits sending a commercial electronic message unless the person has consented to receive it, expressly or by implication, and the message identifies the sender and offers a way to unsubscribe. A recruiter’s email, text or direct message needs consent when it is commercial: when, judging by its content, its links and its contact details, one of its purposes is to encourage the reader to take part in a commercial activity. Answering a candidate’s own question does not need consent. Pitching your agency’s services does. Most recruiting outreach sits between the two, and the safe course is to treat it as commercial.

What makes a message commercial

The test is in section 1(2) of the Act. A message is commercial if it would be reasonable to conclude that one of its purposes is to encourage participation in a commercial activity, looking at what it says, the content its links lead to and the contact information it gives. The Act lists examples: messages that offer to buy, sell or lease a product or service, that offer a business, investment or gaming opportunity, or that advertise or promote either.

The Act defines an electronic address as the address of an email, instant messaging or telephone account, or any similar account. A text message or a message in a chat app is caught the same way as an email.

For recruiters, some cases are clear:

  • An email to a hiring manager offering your agency’s placement services offers a service. It is commercial.
  • A message to a candidate that promotes a paid résumé review, or links to a page selling one, has a commercial purpose even if most of it is about a job.
  • An email asking someone for permission to send them job alerts is commercial too. Section 1(3) treats a request for consent to send commercial messages as a commercial message itself, so a cold email asking “may we keep in touch?” needs a basis of its own.

The harder case is a plain message about a job. The Act’s examples do not mention employment, and whether a message describing an opening encourages participation in a commercial activity depends on its content and context. The law has not settled the point. Our advice: for outreach to people who have not asked to hear from you, treat the message as commercial and meet the rules below.

Some messages fall outside the consent rule, or outside section 6 altogether:

  • Replies. The regulations exclude a message sent in response to a request, inquiry or complaint, or otherwise solicited by the person who receives it. A candidate who asks whether the night shift is still open can be answered.
  • Messages the law requires. Messages sent to satisfy a legal obligation are excluded as well. In Ontario, an employer with 25 or more employees that interviews an applicant for a publicly advertised job must tell them, within 45 days of the last interview, whether a hiring decision has been made, and the notice may go by email or text.
  • Current employees. A message that only gives information directly related to an employment relationship or benefit plan the person is currently in needs no consent, though it must still identify you and include an unsubscribe mechanism. A shift change for an assignment employee on a current assignment is the kind of message this exception describes. An offer of a different job may not fit it, because the exception covers messages that do nothing else.
  • Personal and family relationships. Section 6 does not apply to a message an individual sends to someone with whom they have a personal or family relationship, as the regulations define those terms.
  • Live calls and voice recordings. Two-way voice calls between individuals, and voice recordings sent to a telephone account, are outside section 6.

Express consent is the person saying yes. When you ask for it, section 10(1) requires you to state clearly and simply the purpose and who is asking. The CRTC’s regulations set out what the request must include: the name you carry on business under, your mailing address, a telephone number, email address or web address, a statement that the person can withdraw consent, and, if you ask on behalf of a client, which of you is asking for whom. Consent may be given orally or in writing.

On an application form, that can be one box the candidate ticks, apart from the application itself: “Yes, [agency name] may email or text me about other job openings. [Mailing address], [email address]. I can withdraw this consent at any time.” A candidate who only wants the job they applied for can leave it blank.

Implied consent exists only in the situations section 10(9) lists: an existing business or non-business relationship as the Act defines them; an address the person published conspicuously or gave you, where the message is relevant to their role in a business or official capacity; and circumstances set out in regulations. Each comes with conditions, some expire, and none mentions job applicants. If you rely on one, write down which one and when it ends.

What every commercial message must contain

Consent is one half of section 6. The other half is what the message must contain, and it applies to every commercial message within section 6, including the current-employee messages that need no consent:

  • the name you carry on business under and, if you send on someone else’s behalf, their name and a statement of which of you is sending for whom;
  • your mailing address and a telephone number reaching a person or voicemail, an email address or a web address, valid for at least 60 days after the message is sent;
  • an unsubscribe mechanism that costs the recipient nothing, works through the same electronic means where that is practicable, and points to an address or link that stays valid for at least 60 days.

The regulations require this information and the unsubscribe mechanism to be set out clearly and prominently, and the mechanism must be easy to use. A request to unsubscribe must be honoured without delay, and no later than 10 business days after it was sent.

Keep the proof

If your consent is ever questioned, section 13 puts the burden on you: whoever claims consent has to prove it. For each person, keep the basis you relied on, the date and channel, and the exact wording they saw or the version of the form they used.

The penalties are large. The maximum administrative monetary penalty is $1,000,000 per violation for an individual and $10,000,000 for any other person. In the CompuFinder case, the CRTC found that a training company had sent commercial emails without consent and with a faulty unsubscribe mechanism, and set the penalty at $200,000 instead of the $1.1 million in the original notice of violation. The Federal Court of Appeal dismissed the company’s appeals in 2020.

A worked example

Take a hypothetical agency with 30 assignment employees and 4,000 past applicants in its database. It wants to announce 12 forklift positions at a client’s distribution centre. Sorting the list before anything is sent:

  • The 900 applicants who ticked the job-alerts box gave express consent. They get the email, with the agency’s identification and an unsubscribe link.
  • The 30 current assignment employees are in an employment relationship, but an offer of new positions may go beyond information about their current one, so the employee exception may not cover it. Check the basis for each person, as for anyone else.
  • The other applicants have no recorded consent. Unless the agency has another basis it can prove, they do not get the email. An email asking them to opt in is itself a commercial message, so it is not the fix. Post the positions on the agency’s careers page and job boards, and let people apply.
  • Anyone who unsubscribed gets nothing, whatever list they appear on.

This sorting only works if the basis was recorded at the moment each person applied or opted in. Reconstructing it later from old spreadsheets means guessing, and section 13 does not reward guesses.

In practice

In TalentInitiator, each outreach message shows the consent basis recorded for its recipient before a recruiter can approve it, the identification footer comes from a locked template, and anyone on the suppression list is blocked with the reason. The conversations page shows how outreach and approval work.

How to read this post

This post explains the rules in general terms, as they stood on the date above. It is not legal advice for your organization.

Sources

All posts