Structured interviews: building the questions from the job’s real requirements
A structured interview asks every candidate the same job-based questions and scores the answers against a guide written in advance. How to build one, with a worked scoring example.
7 minute readFair screening and interviews
A structured interview asks every candidate the same questions, each one drawn from a requirement of the job, and scores the answers against a guide written before the first interview. Setting one up for a role takes an afternoon. In return you get interviews you can compare, and a record that shows why each candidate moved forward or did not.
In Ontario it is also the approach the Human Rights Commission recommends. Its employer guide, Human Rights at Work, advises preparing set questions in advance, asking every applicant the same ones, basing them on the job’s essential duties and genuine requirements, and drawing up an answer guide and marking scheme before the interviews begin.
Why structure matters under Ontario’s Human Rights Code
Ontario’s Human Rights Code gives every person the right to equal treatment in employment without discrimination because of race, ancestry, place of origin, colour, ethnic origin, citizenship, creed, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, age, record of offences, marital status, family status or disability. Section 23(2) adds that this right is infringed when a written or oral inquiry of an applicant directly or indirectly classifies them by one of those grounds.
Unstructured interviews make both problems more likely. When interviewers improvise, the questions drift from the job to the person, and different candidates hear different questions. The Commission’s guide is direct on the second point: an employer cannot ask some candidates questions it does not ask the others. It also warns that decisions resting on impressions such as “confidence” or whether someone seems “suitable” are hard to defend, because without objective criteria an employer struggles to explain why a candidate was or was not qualified.
Outside Ontario the details change, but not the logic. Federally regulated employers fall under the Canadian Human Rights Act, which treats a written or oral inquiry that expresses a limitation or preference based on a prohibited ground as a discriminatory practice. Quebec’s Charter of human rights and freedoms forbids requiring information about any of its listed grounds in an application form or interview, unless the information is useful for assessing the qualifications the job requires or for an affirmative action program already in place. A process that ties every question to the job works under all three.
Start from the job, not the résumé
List what the person in the role actually does, then separate the essential duties from the occasional or merely preferable ones. The Commission’s guide suggests four questions for deciding whether a duty is essential: how often it is performed, how much time it takes, how it fits with the other duties, and how the job would change if it were removed.
Take a hypothetical evening shift lead at a distribution centre. The draft posting lists six requirements. After that review, four are essential:
- Assigns and rebalances work for a crew of 12 during the shift.
- Applies the site’s safety procedures and stops unsafe work.
- Reports shift results in the warehouse system before handover.
- Resolves disagreements between crew members on the floor.
“Familiar with our client’s product lines” turns out to be something every new lead learns in the first week, so it becomes training. “Excellent written English” turns out to mean writing a five-line handover note, so it becomes part of the reporting requirement instead of a separate judgment of someone’s writing.
Turn each requirement into a question
Write one or two questions for each essential requirement. Two kinds work well:
- Past behaviour. “Tell me about a shift where two people called in sick. What did you change, and how did it turn out?”
- A situation from the job. “Halfway through a shift, a forklift operator skips the pre-use check because a load is late. What do you do?”
Each question should be answerable by anyone who can do the job, wherever they learned it. Avoid questions that reward a particular background, such as asking about one employer’s software when the skill is general. If a language skill is a requirement, test the language the job uses: a handover note written during the interview tells you more than an impression of someone’s accent.
Decide your follow-up rules now. The Commission’s guide accepts prompts when the panel decides in advance that every candidate can be prompted if an answer misses the question.
Write the answer guide before the first interview
For each question, describe what a weak, an acceptable and a strong answer contain. A five-point scale with three written anchors is enough. For the sick-call question:
- 1: No example, or an example where the problem was left to someone else.
- 3: A real example: the candidate moved people to cover the gap but does not say how they checked the result.
- 5: A real example with the change made, how it was explained to the crew and what the candidate checked before handover.
Writing the anchors forces the panel to agree on what a good answer is before they meet anyone. It also keeps the standard from moving when a candidate the panel likes walks in.
Score independently, then compare
Give each question a weight that reflects how much its requirement matters, and have each interviewer score alone before any discussion. With five questions weighted 3, 2, 2, 2 and 1, the weights add up to 10, so the maximum is 50.
Suppose two interviewers score candidate A like this:
- Interviewer 1 gives 4, 3, 5, 3 and 4: a weighted total of 12 + 6 + 10 + 6 + 4 = 38.
- Interviewer 2 gives 4, 2, 5, 3 and 4: a weighted total of 12 + 4 + 10 + 6 + 4 = 36.
They differ by one point on one question. The panel looks at what the candidate said against the anchors for that question, agrees on a score and writes down why. When two scores for the same answer are two or more points apart, go back to the notes instead of splitting the difference. Either one interviewer heard something the other missed, or the anchor is unclear and needs fixing before the next interview.
The same process for everyone, with accommodation
Structure is not rigidity. The Commission’s guide says the process should be the same for all candidates and decided in advance, subject to accommodation needs. A candidate who needs extra time, another format or someone to read the questions aloud is still assessed on the same job requirements, with the questions or the format adapted where the accommodation calls for it.
Ontario’s accessibility standards add a specific duty. When you select an applicant for an assessment or interview, you must tell them that accommodations are available on request for the materials and processes you will use. If they ask, you must consult them and provide or arrange a suitable accommodation.
Keep what you wrote
Keep the questions, the answer guide, each interviewer’s notes and scores, and the agreed result. In Ontario, a person who believes their rights under the Code were infringed generally has one year after the incident to apply to the Human Rights Tribunal, so a record you delete sooner may be gone when you need it.
Employers covered by Ontario’s job-posting rules must also tell each interviewed applicant, within 45 days of their last interview, whether a hiring decision has been made, and keep a copy of that information for three years. A structured interview makes the notice easy: the decision and the scores behind it are already written down.
In practice
Most of the effort goes into the first version for a role: the duty list, the questions and the anchors. Later rounds reuse them, and the review after each round is mostly about whether an anchor needs sharpening.
In TalentInitiator, interview questions come from the job’s approved rubric, every criterion carries a job-related justification, and the evaluation quotes the part of the answer each score relies on. A recruiter approves the rubric before anyone is scored and makes every decision. Our interviews page shows how it works.
How to read this post
This post explains the rules in general terms, as they stood on the date above. It is not legal advice for your organization.
Sources
- Human Rights Code (Ontario)
- O. Reg. 191/11, s. 23 (recruitment, assessment or selection process)
- Employment Standards Act, 2000, s. 8.6 (interview outcome within 45 days) In force since January 1, 2026
- Employment Standards Act, 2000, s. 15 (posting, application and notice records) In force since January 1, 2026
- OHRC, Human Rights at Work (application forms, interviews and hiring decisions)
- Canadian Human Rights Act (federally regulated employers)
- Quebec Charter of human rights and freedoms, ss. 10, 18.1, 18.2 and 20 (hiring)